Tested: The Best Men’s Zip-up Hoodies for a Relaxed Look

Let’s get one thing clear: there are few pieces of attire more integral to any wardrobe than the hoodie. Whether it’s simple or clad with graphics, there is practically no extra layer more capable of taking on the day than an easy-wearing garment that offers a bit of elemental protection. Some hoodies from certain brands may go for dubious amounts on the resale market, and others boast a parallel price tag on the shelves, and these are merely signs of just how coveted these pieces can be. Some pricey may offer superior composition, but there are certain elements that they don’t feature — like a zipper. With that in mind, we’ve put together the following hands-on guide to narrow down the absolute best zip-up hoodies from across the fashion world.

How We Tested

If you’ve been with us for our Tested series, you know the drill by now, but for those of you just joining us, here’s a bit about our selection process. We don’t just cover any old hoodies here; it takes dedicated research online, paying close attention to reviews and brand status, along with our collective personal experiences over here at HICONSUMPTION. Each hoodie recommendation (and the label it’s from) is backed by our years of experience in the style space.

It’s tempting to just hang out and watch Netflix whenever we’re testing something like a hoodie, but we get hands-on with them, putting them through the wringer to see if they live up to their claims of comfort, durability, and warmth. We’re not just throwing these on and calling it a day, either; we’re also testing how they fit and look (is that relaxed fit really relaxed?), and how big that hood really is. While we’ve already covered our favorite pullover hoodies (you can check that out over here), we figured it was time to round up some of our favorite zip-ups. Do keep in mind that we’re based in Los Angeles, so the coldest days were over/under 50℉.

Measurements: I’m 6’2″ and wear size 34×30 pants. For hoodies, I usually go for an XL (and a relaxed fit if I can), but we’ve included a variety of fits here, and I aim to be objective.

What to Look For

Material: Hoodies are typically made with a blend of cotton and polyester ( with a majority leaning towards cotton). If you want a more durable pick, you can go for a 100% cotton hoodie, but it won’t offer the moisture-wicking properties of polyester. Synthetic materials are best for active or athleisure wear, and for those who want a stretchy fabric without synthetics, a jersey knit hoodie is a great choice. Cashmere and wool hoodies are solid picks for colder climates, providing reliable insulation against the elements and a different texture.

Fit: When it comes to fit, a slightly larger hoodie gives you some nice room for lounging, but slim-fitting designs can be just as comfortable and are great for layering (or getting active). For those uncertain about sizing, it’s safe to go with a relaxed fit, as this is probably the most popular look.

Style: Hoodie styles vary mainly in the hood, zipper, pocket style, and color. You’ll usually be choosing between button closures or drawstrings on the hood, along with different-sized pockets, which change the overall look of the hoodie. 

Weight: Hoodies typically range between 10oz and 24oz in weight. Heavier options give you more warmth and durability, with 16oz and above recommended for the most insulation. Lighter hoodies (usually ranging from 8oz to 12oz) are best for getting active and using as mid-layers.

Hood: When it comes to hoods, a larger fit is best for protection in cold weather (or if you just want to hide). But if you don’t wear your hood very often, or like to have it out of the way, it’s best to go for a smaller one.

Uniqlo Sweat Full-Zip Long-Sleeve Hoodie

Best Starter Hoodie: Anything from Uniqlo tends to serve as an ideal entry-level piece, and this is no exception. The brand’s full-zip hoodie is crafted from shedding-resistant yarn and a hood with added fabric that dries quickly. Its exterior is crafted from nothing but cotton, which seeps its way into a comfortable rib and hood lining of cotton and polyester. You always know what to expect from the Japanese giant, and it offers more of the same here.

Uniqlo has carved out its niche of affordable pieces that are still high quality, and this hoodie is maybe the perfect example of this. For just $50, you’re getting a surprisingly high-quality hoodie made entirely of cotton in the body, with a quick-drying hood lining using a cotton and polyester blend. You’re even getting YKK hardware, which most other hoodies in this price range definitely do not have. As for the fit, this was mostly true to size, with a slightly baggier fit in the chest and arms, with ribbed cuffs to keep the sleeves in place. Uniqlo has also updated the lining to be pilling-resistant, and it has a sort of dry hand feel that’s similar to a Jersey knit. The warmth here was solid as well, keeping me warm at around 50°F (even when unzipped). It’s finished with a classic kangaroo pocket, premium spindle heads and eyelets, and a contoured hood.

Honestly, I was super impressed with this hoodie, and don’t have any gripes that jumped out at me after testing. If I had to pick something, though, I would say that the oversized hood might be a little too big for some, which is great for protection but not the best if you prefer smaller hoods.

Verdict: Uniqlo’s budget apparel honestly speaks for itself, but this hoodie was especially impressive considering the build quality, YKK hardware, and overall look. If you’re looking for a budget hoodie that doesn’t look (or feel) like a budget hoodie, this one’s for you.

Carhartt Loose Fit Midweight Full-Zip Sweatshirt

Best Relaxed Hoodie: The trusted workwear brand and fashion industry darling Carhartt always meet the mark when it comes to reasonably priced garments that are built to last. Just like this midweight hoodie that’s made with a half cotton and half polyester blend, for the right amount of breathable durability. And it has two large handwarmer pockets on the front for storage and chilly days.

We got hands-on with the pullover (and waterproof) version of this hoodie over on our guide to the best pullover hoodies, and it’s one of my favorite hard-wearing hoodies. With the zip-up version here, you’re getting a 10.5-ounce blend of half cotton and half polyester for some natural breathability and moisture control, with a fleece inner layer that feels super soft on the skin (and bolsters the warmth here quite a bit, having no problem keeping me warm in ~50°F weather). There’s a (slightly) oversized three-piece hood giving you plenty of coverage with a drawcord closure, and rib knit cuffs on the sleeves to keep the cold out. Thankfully, the split kangaroo pockets are also lined with fleece, so you’re getting some extra warmth for your hands, and it’s finished with a full-length brass zipper and that unmistakable Carhartt patch on the left hand pocket.

The fit here is definitely oversized and loose, which is something that personally like when it comes to clothing in general (especially with casual garments like hoodies), but I get that not everyone is the same, and some may prefer a more true-to-size fit. If this sounds like you, I recommend going a size down if you like the look of this one. 

Verdict: There’s a reason that Carhartt has been such a staple in the space: the label’s reliable build quality and timeless aesthetic never fail to impress, and manages to be modern at the same time, just like this hoodie.

Flint and Tinder 10-Year Full Zip Hoodie

Best Durable Hoodie: Flint and Tinder’s 10-Year Hoodie is intended to last, you guessed it, one whole decade, and you can even tack on a couple more years if you play your cards right. Thanks to the Huckberry house brand’s 10-Year Guarantee, any signs of wear and tear can be repaired if you’re looking to rid the hoodie of its presumably distressed look. Plus, as a result of its intercontinental composition, the 10-Year Hoodie is composed of elements from all around the country, featuring zippers from Georgia, twill tape from Philadelphia, and a heavyset fleece from South Carolina, practically deeming it a wearable traveler’s guide.

Like the Carhartt pick above, we also took a closer look at the pullover variant of this hoodie on our other hoodie guide, and it was one of our favorite US-made hoodies. It’s cut and sewn in our hometown of Los Angeles with cotton from the Mississippi Delta, features twill-reinforced seams made in Philadelphia, and heavy-duty zippers crafted in Georgia, meaning everything about this hoodie is definitely American. The durable blend of cotton and polyester (70/30) here has a really nice dry hand feel on the outer layer, with a plush fleece lining that’s great for insulation (no problems with warmth or wind protection here in around 53°F). One detail that I really appreciated is the inner pocket on the bottom left of the inner layer, which features a patch similar to the label’s waxed trucker jacket, denoting the product’s fabric and construction origin. Other small details like the YKK hardware and metal tips on the draw cord really elevate this pick and show that FnT took the time to get everything just right. Not only is this built and guaranteed to last 10 years, but FnT will repair your hoodie should anything happen to it, no questions asked. 

While this hoodie is advertised as having a relaxed fit that’s true to size, I’d say it leans a bit more towards true to size, and ran just the slightest bit tight on me (you’re seeing a size XL). If you want a roomier fit, I definitely recommend going a size up.

Verdict: It’s hard to beat a 10-year guarantee, and this US-made hoodie certainly feels like it’ll be around for a while. But it’s not all about durability, as this pick is also incredibly soft, with a nice dry hand feel on the outside that’s akin to those classic hoodies.

American Giant Classic Full Zip Hoodie

Best American-Made Hoodie: American Giant touts its simple zip-up hoodie as the greatest hoodie of all time, which shouldn’t come as much of a surprise from a brand with such a grandiose name. Be that as it may, we can’t blame the Carolinas-based band of traditionalists for their lofty claim because this lowkey piece serves as a durable, quintessential layer. It’s composed of a custom heavyweight fleece and rounded out with a pair of reinforced elbow pads. Indeed, there’s no need to go around searching for other hoodies once this one’s in your closet.

We’re really big fans of American Giant over here because their apparel embodies the definition of high-quality US-made goods. This hoodie here is the perfect example, built with a custom heavyweight fleece that has a nice dry hand feel and durability you notice immediately (much like Carhartt’s hoodie). The inner fleece layer has a slightly rougher feel to it, but it’s still soft and noticeably warmer than other fleece linings. Much like Flint and Tinder’s hoodie, American Giant really went all out with the details here, outfitting the hoodie with custom YKK hardware, reinforced elbow patches, and a double-lined hood for extra warmth. The fit is also very similar to Flint and Tinder’s hoodie, with a slimmer fit that’s been pre-shrunk and washed, and it’s finished with double-needle straddle-stitching and a small logo patch on the bottom left of the hem. Lauded as “The Greatest Hoodie Ever Made,” after wearing and testing this pick, I can confidently say it’s definitely among the greats.

My only gripes with this pick are the slim fit and the oversized hood, which aren’t a deal breaker at all (and some may prefer their hoodies that way). The big hood, for example, is super useful for blocking wind (especially since it’s double-layered), and you can easily go for a size up for a roomier fit. 

Verdict: Supporting American manufacturing and getting an incredibly comfortable hoodie seems like a good deal to me. Especially when the hoodie is as comfortable as this one, boasting a heavyweight fleece construction that’s as soft as it is warm.

Nike Sportswear Tech Fleece Windrunner

Best Active Hoodie: Nike’s Tech apparel is having a bit of a moment right now, both on and offline, but this newfound status doesn’t change the basics. Nike’s innovative blend of cotton jersey and synthetic layers makes for a remarkably lightweight fabric. And since releasing a decade ago, it’s become a staple in Nike’s Tech lineup, and the Tech Fleece Windrunner is maybe the most classic out of the bunch.

You’ve seen this hoodie everywhere, especially over the last few years, as it’s been blowing up on social media. The new fleece Nike is using here just feels buttery smooth (even with the updated material blend that uses recycled materials), and you’re getting the same lightweight feel that the tech lineup is lauded for. This is really a true blend between active and casual, built with a partial elastic hem and elastic cuffs on the sleeve to keep everything in place, and an athletic fit that’s easy to layer with. It also features dropped shoulders and a paneled sleeve design that allows for a better range of motion, and for storage, you get two very generous hand pockets with a zippered closure. The scuba hood here is a personal favorite of mine, and adds to the sort of futuristic vibe of the hoodie with a turtleneck adjacent look. 

I really have no criticisms with this hoodie, but I understand if it looks a bit too technical for some. I will say that the fit here is definitely a little baggier than expected, but you can just size down for a more athletic fit (although it’s advertised as athletic on the site already).

Verdict: Don’t let the hype of Nike Tech hoodies deter you here; while fashion ebbs and flows, lightweight comfort, and a buttery soft fleece are timeless. It makes for a great active hoodie, or a reliable wardrobe staple for lazy days when you don’t know what to wear.

Todd Snyder Midweight Full Zip Hoodie

Best Retro Hoodie: There’s no shortage of cashmere hoodies on the market — however, there is a solid handful of them that outweigh the rest, with Todd Snyder’s high-end entry at the top of the list. The New York designer’s hoodie is uncannily cozy and crafted from nothing but the finest cashmere. Plus, if that doesn’t sound luxurious enough, it is rounded out with suede elbow patches and a flattering tailored fit. The brand labels this one of its “luxe essentials,” going to show that even the simple things in life warrant a high-end makeover now and again.

The Todd Snyder and Champion collabs are always a hit and capture that classic look that everyone’s favorite old-school activewear and gym clothes have. This time around, the duo is tackling the classic zip-up, using 18 ounces of garment-dyed French terry cotton for an insanely soft hoodie. This softness (and the look) is thanks to the reverse weave fabric that’s been cut on the cross-grain, giving it a velvety smooth hand feel. Everything about this hoodie is truly a love letter to vintage gear, from the antique brass hardware to the retro jock tag nodding to old-school Champion gear, and it really gives the piece a lived-in look and feel. The fit here is listed as “classic,” and I’d personally say that it feels pretty true to size, with a hood that isn’t too big (i.e. not covering your eyes). You’re also getting rib cuffs and a waistband to lock in heat, and stretchy side seam panels for added mobility. 

The only thing going against this hoodie is the size of the hand pockets, which are pretty small (even just for putting your hands in). I found that a small part of my wrists were exposed while using them, which isn’t a super big deal, but it’s not ideal for colder weather. It has comes in a tailored fit, which may warrant a size up if you prefer your hoodies to be more relaxed-fitting.

Verdict: We’re big fans of these Todd Snyder and Champion collabs, especially when they’re channeling that retro look, using small details and French terry to make a hoodie that looks and feels truly lived-in.

Reigning Champ Lightweight Terry Full Zip Hoodie

Best Lightweight Hoodie: One would be remiss to overlook the prominence of performance brands that make their way from the Great North, with Reigning Champ serving as an ideal example to pick from a surfeit of them. Its Midweight Terry Hoodie is made by hand in Canada and makes for an excellent choice, which shouldn’t come as a surprise knowing that the brand is tailored to crafting top-notch essentials. The fully cotton-crafted piece comes equipped with a pair of semi-raglan sleeves for additional warmth and style, and on top of that, it is rounded out with durable flatlock seams, resulting in a lack of abrasions.

Reigning Champ is one of our favorite labels over here at HICONSUMPTION, because its blend of athleisure and streetwear results in some of the best basics and athletic wear you can get. This hoodie is no exception, boasting a custom two-way YKK zipper, and a French terry construction that has a super smooth hand feel. It’s advertised as a slim fit, but it leans a bit more towards true to size. As is the case with all of Reigning Champ’s apparel, the little details here really take it to the next level, from the flatlock seams to the rib-lined hood. As for the hood here, I really liked the smaller size (especially since this hoodie has a more athletic-leaning fit and feel), but it’s also double-layered, meaning you get some solid warmth and protection as well. You’re also getting some side seam panels for more mobility, giving it a more unique silhouette as well. Again, this hoodie is more lightweight and geared toward an athletic fit (similar to Nike’s hoodie), which means it’s a little difficult to layer anything besides a tee (or maybe a thin flannel) underneath.

While the warmth here is definitely solid, this hoodie is on the thinner side for sure, which means it’s not quite as warm as the thicker picks in the guide. This isn’t a bad thing, though, especially now that Spring is around the corner, as this makes for a great pick to wear during the shoulder months.

Verdict: Reigning Champ has really perfected this unique style of elevated athleisure with a blend of streetwear, and this hoodie is a great example; it’s clean, simple, and made with high-quality hardware and materials.

Zip-Ups Comparison Chart

ZIP-UPS VS. PULLOVERS

No matter how chic your favorite pullover hoodie might be, it’s bound to get a little suffocating. Ergo, there aren’t many garments that have proven to be as ideal and convenient as a zip-up hoodie. While there is an abundance of other jackets that can be classified into this particular bracket, there is a countless number of brands that take immense pride in the fact that their zipped hoodies are debatably the best you can find, bridging that gap between a comfy sweatshirt and protective outer layer.

WHEN SHOULD YOU WEAR A ZIP-UP HOODIE?

Given the convenience of hoodies, they work well on their own, but make sure it’s a style you enjoy and a fit that’s a little more (or a lot more) relaxed. Zip-ups also make for solid layers, and if that’s what you plan on wearing one for, then a standard fit is best (not too big or small). So your favorite tee (or a warm shirt in cold weather) is the perfect inner layer if you’re wearing it solo, and a thicker jacket (like denim or leather) works as an outer layer.

Honorable Mentions

We had a chance to get hands-on with Vollebak’s 100 Year Zip Through Hoodie over on our other hoodie guide, and it’s one of the most impressive hoodies (from a design perspective) we’ve come across. Vollebak has also updated it to be softer and more breathable, so now’s the perfect time to grab this fireproof, waterproof, and windproof hoodie.

Hailing from an absolute legend in the menswear space, Ralph Lauren’s Fleece Full-Zip Hoodie is made with a cotton-blend fleece and equipped with a drawstring hood with a waffle-knit lining. It’s finished with that iconic embroidered Polo pony on the chest.

James Perse’s Vintage French Terry Zip Up Hoodie is made entirely with lightweight Supima cotton terry that’s been dyed using a special pigment process to give it a unique look. That means you’re getting an incredibly soft hoodie with a lived-in look and feel right out of the box.

Longtime readers know just how much we love Taylor Stitch over here at HICONSUMPTION, and the label’s Portola Hoodie takes that classic zip-up style and hits it with a blend of Merino wool and nylon. Small details like the antique silver zipper taped back neck elevate the look, and you’re getting some natural breathability and moisture control from the wool.

As one of the true OGs in the techwear space, C.P. Company has paved the way for labels like Arc’teryx with truly futuristic apparel that’s just as rugged as it is stylish. The Cotton Fleece Hooded Sweatshirt may not have those iconic goggles on the hood, but it features a detachable hood and a little lens on the left sleeve.

Tested: The Best Hoodies for Men Right Now

As we said, no matter what type of hoodie you have, they are always incredibly convenient and essential. As a matter of fact, they are so essential that having another one could never hurt. Therefore, we scoured the web to compile the best pullover hoodies in our helpful hands- on guide.