Sleep Tight: 10 Best Mail Order Mattresses

Jul 29, 2019

Category: Living

Mattresses are one of those items that everyone needs but no one wants to go through the mundane trouble of researching and buying. For up until recently, making a trip to a big-box department store in pursuit of a hefty mattress to be tied the roof of your car, lugged home and carried inside only after ferociously disposing of your old mattress was a daunting and arduous task to say the least. But here’s the thing, it was necessary. That is unless you feel that sleeping on the floor of your apartment or home is desirable. Since this clearly isn’t an option, the mattress store lifestyle, unfortunately, plagued lives for years on end.

Recently, however, there’s been a developing trend in the works – one we assume you’re aware of by this point. We’re speaking, of course, on mail order mattresses. Desirable beds brought directly to your home, prepackaged and vacuum sealed in manageable boxes that magically inflated before your eyes. In most cases, these brands will also dispose of your old mattress as well – at the same time. Not only is this delivery system convenient for those in the market for a new bed, but it cuts cost and time through a direct-to-consumer business model. No longer are third-party furniture stores upping the price tag from wholesale. Instead, you’re offered a rate that in most cases is more cost-effective than big-box stores, and highly convenient thanks to the delivery model.

Now, from here the natural response is to beg the question: which mail order delivery mattress brand is the best option for me? Well, the answer to that question all depends on your personal preference. Some of these mattresses run firm, while others a bit softer than their competitors. Some offer options made entirely from foam while some brands utilize springs or other contemporary technology. One thing remains constant though – that the mattress delivery model is here to stay and it’s a safe bet your next purchase will be made online. So, with that in mind, here are 10 brands we feel are worth exploring further in order to discover that perfect combination of comfort and price point.

Tuft & Needle

Founded back in 2012 by two Silicon Valley software engineers, Tuft & Needle also arose out of the unsatisfying experience one of their founders had when making a purchase at a big-box department store. So, taking matters into their own hands, they decided to launch a brand that would forever remove the need to ever pay a premium price for a non-premium mattress.

Enter Phoenix-based Tuft & Needle, the adaptive foam mattress now enjoyed by over half a million Americans. Each option utilizes their T&N Adaptive Foam developed through customer feedback that’s then paired with a high-quality support layer helping to form an ideal foundation for each and every mattress they ship. Also, with ideal support, mattresses from Tuft & Needle work react properly to any amount of pressure placed on them. It’s worth noting though, that these are then on the firmer side of things. Finally, each mattress utilizes three ways to keep you cooler at night so you can say so long to sweating through the night during the summer months.

Purchase: $325+

Cocoon by Sealy

Most of us are familiar with Sealy. However, it’s the Cocoon Classic that really catches our attention. As a whole, you can expect the same quality construction here as with traditional Sealy mattresses but with a premium fabric cover and perfect fit memory foam to keep things as comfortable as possible.

Speaking of perfect fit memory foam, it’s their personalized memory foam that’s actually available in either Cocoon soft or Cocoon firm to various degrees based on your preferences. Additionally, buyer’s can opt for a soft layer offering a cozier and more – as they put it – “in-the-bed” feel as well as a firm layer for the opposite effect. Each option also comes equipped with their 100-night trial to test things out for yourself, free shipping to your home, and a 10-year warranty for some additional peace of mind.

Purchase: $399+


What started out of simple annoyance surrounding the now antiquated mattress buying experience has now expanded into one of the more formidable and well-known brands in the mail order mattress world. Here, the goal is simple: to help people sleep better. So with that in mind, Leesa looks to offer not only quality mattresses for the masses but pepper in a bit of philanthropy into their business model.

As far as their mattresses are concerned, each foam option features 10-inches of their propriety foam construction to help offer uniform pressure relief while sleeping. It’s also aimed to adapt to all body types and sleeping positions through balanced body contouring and an exclusive Avena top cooling layer for those hot nights. Additionally, you can rest easy knowing each USA-made Leesa mattress comes with a 100 night trial period, they offer free shipping and returns on all their products – including their bedding collections – and for every mattress sold Leesa will plant a tree and donate a mattress to those in need for every ten sold.

Purchase: $425+


With over 25 years in the mattress business, Bear’s founding family was initially motivated by the principles of customer service and ideal user experience when making a purchase. It’s what you had to do at the time to remain afloat in an industry where the purchasing experience was highly looked down upon. So, when these mattress maestros decided to build Bear Mattress, such honest and transparent business policies were always put first.

Such is the case with their product as well – built with premium graphite gel-memory foam that’s engineered for ideal cooling and comfort. Such material quickly adapts to each individual’s needed support while their clinically-proven Celliant Cover absorbs the body’s natural heat and reflects far infrared light back to the skin helping you recover quicker while you sleep better. Clearly, it’s built with an athletic individual in mind but also functions as an ideal option for those who simply want a quality night’s rest. Oh, and it’s made right here in the USA and comes with a 100-night sleeping trial.

Purchase: $500+


If you’re looking for a premium luxury mattress without the premium price tag found at mattress retailers, then Saatva could be worth a bit of further investigation. Starting from humble beginnings, they’re now one of the largest online-only mattress companies around boasting 19 production factories and 135 fulfillment centers across the US.

As far as their mattresses are concerned, here we find each mattress built with a high-quality feature known as coil-on-coil construction. Through this method, the lower coil unit features a connected hourglass steel support base while the top coil unit boasts an individually-wrapped system that easily contours and adapts to your body. They’re built with care – made to last anywhere between 10-15 years which is almost unheard of in the mattress world – and they offer multiple comfort levels depending on your sleeping preferences on a scale of 1-10 based on either softness or firmness. These products are also made with eco-friendly materials and come with guaranteed nationwide home delivery and setup.

Purchase: $599+


If we were to label any one of these brands as a “disrupter” in the mattress industry, it would most likely be Casper. They were there in the early days of mail order mattress delivery, and as a self-described “sleep company,” have worked tirelessly to have their brand name associated with the term “mattress.”

For the most part, their mattresses are built from a hybrid-foam construction, featuring a deliberate combination of foams from the industry. Together, there are three options available: 3-layer, 4-layer, and 5-layer that are all purposed to help sleepers attain that desired state of sleep nirvana they crave. As far as mattresses are concerned their three options are The Essential, The Casper (which also happens to be their most popular), and The Wave – all of which respectively follow their multi-layered system. They also offer a 100-night trial to see if the bed is right for you as well as free shipping and returns on all their products.

Purchase: $600+


What’s better than a personalized mattress delivered directly to your home? Yeah, we couldn’t think of anything either. Here, Helix offers a fully-integrated made-to-order experience for the user, something mattress retailers could only dream of accomplishing, thus working to make this buying process as simple and straightforward as possible.

Through the Helix buying experience, they’ll ask you a series of questions about your sleeping habits, sleeping position, potential pressure points, getting hot at night, waking up with pain the in the morning, etc. From here, your desired mattress softness is gauged, as well as the length of time you’ve owned your current mattress. Helix will then compile this data and build you the ideal foam mattress based on individual wants and needs. Each option is built via varying degrees of Helix dynamic foam, pocketed micro coils, and a high-grade polyfoam. They’ll even give you the option of either a blended or dual comfort mattress to suit your sleeping partner’s needs as well.

Purchase: $600+


In terms of a branding and marketing strategy, Purple most definitely has the most memorable mail order mattress. Just take a look at their website and see for yourself. And a far as their story/mattress is concerned, Purple wants to offer a versatile mattress that anyone with just about any individual preferences can afford and enjoy.

It all starts with their No Pressure Mattress, boasting the ability to support your back like a firm mattress yet remaining able to cradle both your hips and shoulder like a soft mattress. Simply put, it’s the best of both worlds – designed as a post-memory foam option that’s temperature-neutral, never leaves a body indent, and made from non-toxic, food grade material. It’s all thanks to their Hyper-Elastic Polymer materials that make up each and every mattress they build. So, what are the benefits? How about a durable no-feel motion transfer, pressure-releasing comfort and support, free flow air design, and a 100 night trial with absolutely no risk involved.
Purchase: $699+


Weird name, serious mattress. At least that’s our impression of this sleek and well-designed option boasting micro-targeted support. It’s what their Michigan-based design team was able to put together after teaming up with the goal of releasing an efficient, quality bed that’s made of materials that don’t compromise your health.

So, what resulted from the research is a multi-layer option absent of filler that commonly found in traditional foam mattresses. Here, each layer of an Oso mattress is chosen to conform to rigorous health and safety standards. These include skin-friendly textiles, anti-bacterial makeup, and dust-mite resistant latex in its construction. Also, it’s built to offer both firm and soft qualities in the same boat. Simply rotate (not flip) the mattress 180-degrees for a different sleeping experience should you require one. Each bed is also shipped to your home for free and made right here in the USA. An ideal option for the designer for sure.

Purchase: $700+


As a step-up version of the traditional Leesa mattress, the Sapira works to combine both Leesa’s premium foam layers with their proprietary pocket-spring coils for absolutely superior support. Not to worry, however, this option still falls in line with Leesa’s philosophy of quality-first and comes equipped with their premium cooling and pressure-relieving foams along with an advanced system that responds to your body’s pressure points.

From here, ultimate comfort is key since the Sapira’s individually-wrapped coils gently push back as your body presses onto the mattress. This combination results in a reliable and luxurious sleep experience night after night – leaving you refreshed in the morning to tackle the day. It’s also backed by their 100-night risk-free trial, free shipping and returns, is made right here in the USA, and one is donated every time 10 are sold. Can’t beat that.

Purchase: $975+

Best Gym Equipment For The Homestead

Part of getting a good night’s rest is remaining active during the day. So if you’re looking for a little home exercising equipment to get the heart pumping after work, look no further than these home gym essentials.

HiConsumption is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

More From Living

Luminox & Bear Grylls Made One Seriously Tough Travel Watch

Designed in part and approved by Bear Grylls himself.

Posted By Johnny Brayson

Featured Image

Happier Camper’s Traveler Offers A Big Trailer Feel In A Lightweight Package

Light enough to tow with a station wagon and comes in a WFH format.

Posted By

Mar 4, 2021

Featured Image

Good Luck Finding A Better-Looking Futuristic Cabin Than STIPFOLD’s Blackbird

The concept’s radical angles make for a striking silhouette.

Posted By

Mar 4, 2021

Featured Image

Get All The Way Away Aboard This Space Hotel As Soon As The Year 2025

A 400-person hotel and condo space station available to the public.

Posted By

Mar 2, 2021

Featured Image

Sprinter Van vs. Teardrop Trailer: Which Is Better For Camping?

Would you rather drive your vacation home or tow it behind you?

Posted By

Mar 2, 2021

Featured Image

The 15 Best Affordable Work Desks

Build out your perfect office setup without spending an arm and a leg.

Posted By

Mar 2, 2021